Site Logo

STPrism

Synthesised map of maps

4 min read

Here is a synthesized “Map of Maps” using a Four-Quadrant chart in Mermaid syntax. This map organizes the 28 sources based on two primary axes derived from the texts:

1. The Axis of Definition (Y-Axis): Is the complexity defined by Structure (physical laws, constraints, feedback loops) or Meaning (social agreement, perceptions, narratives)?

2. The Axis of Action (X-Axis): Is the goal to Design/Control (engineer stability, optimize, align) or Learn/Adapt (probe, evolve, navigate uncertainty)?

The Complexity Meta-Map

graph TB
     --- THE COMPASS (Top Level) ---
    subgraph Compass_Zone ["THE COMPASS (Choosing the Map)"]
        direction LR
        Jackson["M.C. Jackson<br/>(SOSM & Critical Systems)<br/>[1]"] 
        --> Rosen["Robert Rosen<br/>(Modeling Relation)<br/>[2]"] 
        --> Mitroff["Ian Mitroff<br/>(Multiple Perspectives)<br/>[3]"]
    end

     Logic: Structure + Design
    subgraph Q1_Zone ["QUADRANT 1: THE CYBERNETIC ARCHITECTS (Structure + Design)"]
        direction LR
        Beer["Stafford Beer<br/>(VSM & Variety)<br/>[4]"] 
        --- Hoverstadt["Patrick Hoverstadt<br/>(Fractal Org)<br/>[5]"] 
        --- Dettmer["H.W. Dettmer<br/>(Constraints/TOC)<br/>[6]"] 
        --- Triz["Triz/Altshuller<br/>(Contradiction Matrix)<br/>[7]"] 
        --- Ladyman["Ladyman & Ashby<br/>(Systemic Design)<br/>[8]"]
    end

     Logic: Meaning + Design
    subgraph Q2_Zone ["QUADRANT 2: THE SOCIAL NAVIGATORS (Meaning + Design)"]
        direction LR
        Ackoff["Russell Ackoff<br/>(Idealized Design)<br/>[9]"] 
        --- Warfield["John Warfield<br/>(Interactive Mgmt)<br/>[10]"] 
        --- Emery["Fred Emery<br/>(DP2/Open Systems)<br/>[11]"] 
        --- Hock["Dee Hock<br/>(Chaordic Design)<br/>[12]"]
    end

     Logic: Structure + Learning
    subgraph Q3_Zone ["QUADRANT 3: THE ADAPTIVE EXPLORERS (Structure + Learning)"]
        direction LR
        Snowden["Dave Snowden<br/>(Cynefin & Probing)<br/>[13]"] 
        --- Taleb["Nassim Taleb<br/>(Antifragility)<br/>[14]"] 
        --- Boisot["Max Boisot<br/>(I-Space/Ashby Space)<br/>[15]"] 
        --- Revans["Reg Revans<br/>(Action Learning)<br/>[16]"] 
        --- Wilk["James Wilk<br/>(Minimalist Intervention)<br/>[17]"] 
        --- Allen["Tim Allen<br/>(Hierarchy/Narrative)<br/>[18]"]
    end

     Logic: Meaning + Learning
    subgraph Q4_Zone ["QUADRANT 4: THE EPISTEMOLOGICAL THERAPISTS (Meaning + Learning)"]
        direction LR
        Checkland["Peter Checkland<br/>(SSM)<br/>[19]"] 
        --- Maturana["Humberto Maturana<br/>(Autopoiesis)<br/>[20]"] 
        --- Rittel["Horst Rittel<br/>(Wicked Problems)<br/>[21]"] 
        --- Eden["Colin Eden<br/>(Cognitive Mapping)<br/>[22]"] 
        --- Lakoff["Lakoff & Bateson<br/>(Framing/Double Description)<br/>[23],[24]"] 
        --- Luhmann["Niklas Luhmann<br/>(Distinction/Closure)<br/>[25]"] 
        --- Pirsig["Robert Pirsig<br/>(Quality/Stuckness)<br/>[26]"] 
        --- Boothroyd["Hylton Boothroyd<br/>(Articulate Intervention)<br/>[27]"] 
        --- Cilliers["Paul Cilliers<br/>(Modesty/Provisional)<br/>[28]"]
        --- OU["OU Course<br/>(Difficulty vs Mess)<br/>[29]"]
    end

     These invisible links force the boxes to stack vertically while preserving internal horizontal flow
    Compass_Zone ~~~ Q1_Zone
    Q1_Zone ~~~ Q2_Zone
    Q2_Zone ~~~ Q3_Zone
    Q3_Zone ~~~ Q4_Zone

    %% CLASS ASSIGNMENTS
    class Jackson,Rosen,Mitroff compass;
    class Beer,Hoverstadt,Dettmer,Triz,Ladyman q1;
    class Ackoff,Warfield,Emery,Hock q2;
    class Snowden,Taleb,Boisot,Revans,Wilk,Allen q3;
    class Checkland,Maturana,Rittel,Eden,Lakoff,Luhmann,Pirsig,Boothroyd,Cilliers,OU q4;

Explanation of the Territories

**1. Q1: The Cybernetic Architects (Structure + Design)**This territory views complexity as a problem of variety and constraints. The focus is on designing the organization’s structure to match the complexity of the environment using feedback loops and attenuation[1][2].

• Key Tools: VSM, Constraints Analysis, Fractal Mapping[3][4].

**2. Q2: The Social Navigators (Meaning + Design)**This territory views complexity as a mess of conflicting purposes. The focus is on designing a shared future (“Idealized Design”) or democratic structures that allow diverse stakeholders to align[5][6].

• Key Tools: Search Conferences, Interactive Management, Chaordic Design[7][8].

**3. Q3: The Adaptive Explorers (Structure + Learning)**This territory assumes the system is too opaque or volatile to be designed. The focus is on probing the environment, managing “safe-to-fail” experiments, and building antifragility to survive shocks[9][10].

• Key Tools: Cynefin, Action Learning, Scanning Agents[11][12].

**4. Q4: The Epistemological Therapists (Meaning + Learning)**This territory locates complexity in the mind of the observer. The focus is on reframing how we think, debating worldviews (“Weltanschauungen”), and understanding how language constructs our reality[13][14].

• Key Tools: SSM, Cognitive Mapping, Second-Order Cybernetics[15][16].

**The Compass (Center)**At the center sits the work of Jackson, Rosen, and Mitroff. These authors argue that no single quadrant is “true.” Instead, one must use a meta-framework (like Jackson’s System of Systems Methodologies) to determine which map is appropriate for the specific problem at hand[17][18].

Graph View